Bender Mennonite Quarterly Review Historiography of the Anabaptist Movement

1956 Article

Anabaptist historiography was formerly the privilege of its enemies. The Anabaptists could not accept part, for from 1528 on the German imperial and national laws threatened death to whatever defender of Anabaptism. Whatsoever attempt to abnegate false accusations was directly followed by persecution and abort. Therefore the opponents of Anabaptism were able to spread the well-nigh absurd assertions concerning the life and doctrine of the Anabaptists without having to face up a rebuttal. They took copious reward of their position. This tearing suppression of the right of self-defense naturally injured the entire Anabaptist alliance, for those who were non in a position to draw their own conclusions from observation had to consider them hostile to the country as well as to religion. The few fanatical manifestations amidst the Anabaptists, which mod research has shown to have occurred largely when their sober leaders had been forcibly removed, were the principal foundation for the attacks of the writers—importantly theologians—of the 16th century. In their hostile attitude the writers made no distinction between the character of tranquility Anabaptism and the farthermost excrescences. The few objective contemporary historians like Sebastian Franck (1499-1543, Chronica, Zeytbuch und Geschychtbibel, 1531) were exceptions and exerted trivial influence. The difficulty of securing a printer also handicapped the Anabaptists in publishing their views. An Amsterdam printer was executed in 1544 for publishing a volume past Menno Simons.

This one-sided mental attitude dominated the torso of church building historical writings far across the 16th century. The very titles of the books dealing with the origin and doctrine of the new brotherhood betray this. One of the oldest writings was Zwingli's In Catabaptistarum Strophas Elenchus of 1527; another of the same year was that by Urban Rhegius which appeared in Augsburg: Wider den newen Taufforden, Notwendighe Warnung an alle Christ gleubigen durch dice diener des Evangelii zu Augsburg. Also of 1527 was J. Bader'due south Brüderliche Warnung für demnewen Abgöttischen orden der Widertäuffer. In 1528 appeared Philipp Melanchthon'due south book, Unterricht wider die Lere der Wiedertauffer verdeutscht durch Justus Jonas, and viii years later the admonition to the princes by the same author, Das weltliche Oberkeitt den Widertaufferen mit leiblicher Straß zu weren schuldig sey. In 1528 Andreas Althamer too wrote a book, Ein kurze Unterricht den Pfarherrn und Predigern in Brandenburg . . . ; it draws the decision that Anabaptist doctrines carried revolt in their train. In 1531 Heinrich Bullinger wrote Von dem unverschampten fräfel, ergerlichem verwyrren und unwarhaftem leeren der selbsgesandten Widertouffern; in 1560 he wrote a second volume, Der widertaufferen Ursprung, fürgang, secten, wäsen, fürneme und gemeine irer Artickel. This method of assail continued in the 17th century. In 1603 Christoph Andreas Fischer published his polemic, Von der widertäuffer verfluchten Ursprung, Gottlosen Lehre und derselber grundtliche Widerlegung, followed in 1607 by his equally venomous book, Der Hutterischen Widertäuffer Taubenkobel. In 1623 Theobaldus Zacharias wrote Widertaufferischer Geist, das ist Glaubwürdiger und historischer Bericht, was Jammer und Elend die alten Widertäuffer gestifftet und angerichtet (repr. by West. A. Mayer at Cöthen in 1701). Note also L. Dick's Adversos impios Anabaptistarum errores (Hagenau, 1530) and Johannes Gast's De Anabaptismi exordio, erroribus, historiis abominandis (Basel, 1544).

These few samples from the literary flood issuing from all the churches are sufficient to bear witness how footling interest there was in treating the Anabaptist movement with justice. These works were used every bit sources by later on historians, who took them over without question; very few historians went back to the original confessional writings of the Anabaptist leaders; information technology occurred to only a few to compare them with the statements of contemporary opponents. Well into the 19th century the great Anabaptist move of the 16th century was uncritically identified with the Peasants' War of 1525 and the events in Münster; Menno Simons was thought to accept gathered the dispersed remnants of the Münster Anabaptists and to have turned them to the ways of peace. But of the persecutions, which lasted in Holland until the last quarter of the 16th century, in Federal republic of germany until the outbreak of the Xxx Years' War, and in Switzerland until the 18th century, and brought a martyr's expiry to thousands, practically nothing was said. Non even the imperial laws against baptism upon confession were mentioned.

The inevitable outcome was that these biased presentations could non hold their ground confronting scholarly investigation every bit soon equally the nature and goals of the Anabaptist move were clearly recognized. It, of class, took several centuries to reach this signal. But when it was reached, an amazing reversal took place in the judgment of scholars regarding Anabaptism. In the meantime many of the Anabaptist ideas, such as liberty of faith and conscience, the rejection of force in religious matters, complete separation of church and state, for which the old Anabaptists had struggled and then long and valiantly, had already become and then unremarkably accepted that the movement, so long despised, now attracted the scholar. "Cheers to the research of recent years," wrote Adolf Harnack (Lehrbuch der Dogmengeschichte Iii, 1910, 772), "the portraits of distinguished Christians from Anabaptist circles have been given us; and not a few of these honorable and potent-minded men are more than comprehensible to u.s. than a heroic Luther or an iron-willed Calvin."

The foundation for this unprejudiced presentation of the Anabaptist movement could non be laid until historians took the problem of becoming acquainted with the writings of Anabaptist leaders and the testimony of the victims of persecution. There was, to be sure, non a wide selection, but the few writings available were sufficient to enable an unprejudiced scholar to form a judgment. Information on their doctrine was plant in the works of Hans Denck, Menno Simons, and Dirk Philips. Their spiritual stature was indicated in their hymns, which were begun in 1535 by the prisoners in the castle at Passau in the oldest Anabaptist hymnal, the Ausbund. A drove of the testimony of the martyrs appeared first in the Dutch martyrbook Het Offer des Heeren (1562), which Tieleman Jansz van Braght expanded into his Martyrs Mirror (1660).

The offset author of church history to brand a complete break with the accepted presentation of Anabaptism was Gottfried Arnold. In his extensive piece of work, Unparteyische Kirchen- und Ketzer-Historie, first published in Frankfurt in 1699 (enlarged 3d ed. Schaffhausen, 1740-1742), he proved the untruth of a series of faux assertions. He was familiar with the writings mentioned to a higher place and recognized the injustice of the church toward dissenting Christians. A factor in his involvement may have been the fact that he was closely connected with the arising Pietism; through the spiritual relatedness of Pietism with Anabaptism he may have been granted a deeper understanding of it than the theologians of the traditional school. He was reproached with prejudice in favor of the "heretics." But this did non preclude his piece of work from actually forming the transition from the orthodox, limited concept of church building history to an objective evaluation of events and processes. Ernst Troeltsch called Arnold's Kirchen- und Ketzer-Historie "a church history which is even today not out-of-date and which can even so be compared with mod church building historians. It covers an incredibly rich field of material and carries the student into the temper of extra-ecclesiastical Protestantism as no other book does" (Sociallehren, 1912, 800).

Nonetheless it took a long time for Arnold's work to notice recognition from scholars. The prejudices confronting circles outside the land church were and so deepseated that the principles represented by, the Anabaptist brotherhood were intentionally overlooked. German writers of church history were still and then much under the spell of the traditional concepts that they could non gratis themselves for objective reporting, and writers of secular history did not investigate into the religious history of the 16th century securely enough to recognize the significance of the Anabaptist movement. They saw in it rather a mere secondary miracle of the Reformation, which must in the nature of things disappear of itself afterward the large churches of the Reformation were firmly established. "At the fourth dimension when the older men of our generation were students," said Walther Köhler in a lecture on Mennonite historical enquiry, "we scarcely heard anything mentioned [most the Anabaptist movement], and if it did happen, a judgment was passed upon information technology in accelerate past the utilise of the word 'fanatics'" (Gedenkschrift, 1925, 173). A familiar type of writing nearly the "heretics" (Anabaptists always one of the chief) was the Ketzer-Historie , Ketzer-Lexikon, or Ketzer-Geschichte ("Ketzer" beingness the equivalent of "heretic"), which flourished in the 18th century.

A more careful cultivation of Mennonite history was made first in Holland, where the Mennonites establish official toleration earlier than in other countries. Hither, afterward the preliminary work done past van Braght, the desire for farther research was already awakened. The big numbers of Mennonites there—in the 17th and 18th centuries about ten per cent of the population of Holland belonged to the Mennonite brotherhood—and their economic prominence brought about a greater attending to their own history. In improver the numerous polemics of their opponents compelled them to make an attentive study of the sources. Since in Germany in that location was no literature of this kind, German writers oftentimes dealt merely with the Dutch Anabaptists.

The oldest historical work produced by the Mennonites was published anonymously in 1615 under the title, Het beginsel en voortganck der geschillen, scheuringen, en verdeeltheden onder de cistron die Doopsgesinden Genoemt worden. For a long time it served with Het Offering des Heeren and the Martyrs Mirror equally 1 of the 3 principal sources for the history of the Dutch Mennonites in the 16th century. 1 hundred years later, in 1720, J. Chr. Jehring published a German translation (Gründliche Historie). Nigh this time the works of Herman Schijn, a Mennonite historian, also began to appear. A work of importance was Geschiedenis der Mennoniten in three volumes, 1743-45, by Schijn and Gerardus Maatschoen; another was Nachrichten von dem gegenwärtigen Zustand der Mennoniten, written past the German historian, Southward. F. Rues, published at Jena in 1743, and in a Dutch translation in 1745.

In the 19th century new interest awoke in Holland through the influence of Samuel Müller (1785-1875), a professor at the Amsterdam Mennonite Seminary, who published the ]aarboekje voor de Doopsgezinde Gemeenten (1837-1850). Due south. Blaupot 10 Cate (1807-1884) did outstanding regional histories. The historical piece of work of J. K. de Hoop Scheffer (1819-1892), too a professor at the Amsterdam Seminary, and the outstanding authority on the Reformation in The netherlands, was also epoch-making. He brought to light the oldest sources, which he used in many works of lasting value. Aslope of de Hoop Scheffer, Samuel Cramer (1842-1931), professor at the Seminary, deserves credit for his publication of rare 16th-century books dealing with the Anabaptists, in the Bibliotheca Reformatoria Neerlandica, the noted collection of works from the time of the Dutch Reformation, which he edited (1903-1914).

An abundance of historical treatises appeared in the Doopsgezinde Bijdragen, 1861-1919. Dutch Mennonite historiography was brought to a climax with the work of W. J. Kühler (1874-1946) and North. van der Zijpp, both professors at the Seminary. Kühler devoted 3 volumes to the 16th- and 17th-century Dutch Anabaptists (1932-1945) and van der Zijpp presented a brief history of the Dutch Mennonites from the beginning to 1952. Cornelius Krahn, the author of the latest consummate biography of Menno Simons (1936), summarized the "Historiography of the Dutch Mennonites" in Church building History, September 1944, and Mennonite Quarterly Review, October 1944. Eberhard Teufel presented an annotated bibliography pertaining to the Dutch Mennonites entitled "Täufertum und Quäkertum im Lichte der neueren Forschung" in Theologische Rundschau, No. 1 and two (1941) 21-48; No. 2 (1948) 161-81. W. Köhler'due south "Das Täufertum im Lichte der neueren Kirchengeschichtsforschung" (Archiv f. Ref.-Gesch. 1940-48) as well contained valuable historiographical textile on Dutch Anabaptism. (See Historiography, Netherlands)

In Germany in the 17th century presentations of the whole of Anabaptist history were predominantly in the Latin language. The best-known works are those of A. Meshovius, Historiae Anabaptisticae Libri Septem (Cologne, 1617) and J. H. Ottius, Annates Anabaptistici (Basel, 1672). Since the middle of the 18th century German research scholars have engaged in the written report of Anabaptist history. In his copious collection of sources on Swiss Reformation history (Beyträge zur Erläuterung der Kirchen-Reformations-Geschichten des Schweitzerlandes, Zürich, 1741-53), the Swiss scholar J. C. Füsslin published valuable materials on Swiss Anabaptist history. On the Anabaptist movement in Bavaria in the 16th century V. A. Winter published in 1809 a bitty presentation (Geschichte der baierischen Wiedertäufer) based on several archival sources, in which he nevertheless completely misinterpreted their character. He even attempted to justify the Anabaptist persecutions against Kant'due south conception of the conscienceless graphic symbol of the heresy judges. In the Anabaptist movement he saw but mischief and ruin to the country (p. 162). The results of more recent inquiry were used by Siegmund Riezler in his sensitive presentation in Geschichte Bayerns (1903).

The first comprehensive history of the Anabaptists (Geschichte der Taufe und Taufgesinnten) was published in 1789 past Joh. Aug. Starck, the Hessian court chaplain. Starck was severely attacked by the rationalistic fly; he called his volume a sort of defense of his theological position (p. 6). Beside the writings (1821, 1829) of G. L. von Reiswitz and Friedrich Wadzeck information technology was the most reliable informative work on the history of the Mennonites in the first centuries up to that fourth dimension. J. Hast's Geschichte der Wiedertäufer (1836), written past a Catholic, is typical of the early 19th century. The liberal Karl Hagen (Deutschlands . . . Verhältnis im Re f.-Zeitalter IV, 1844) and the orthodox Max Goebel (Geschichte des christlichen Lebens Ii, 1848) began a juster objective reporting.

A great impetus was given to the report of Anabaptist history virtually the eye of the 19th century by the noted Old Catholic historian, Carl A. Cornelius, who by his thorough research (east.thousand., Geschichte des Münsterischen Aufruhrs, 1855-1860) sought to fathom the nature and significance of Anabaptism, and thus came to the conclusion that the movement emanated from more than worthy motives than the historians, secular and religious, had up to that time given it credit for.

In rapid sequence thorough investigations of the Anabaptist move of the 16th century were now published, throwing lite upon this hitherto neglected co-operative of church history. For a while well-nigh every year produced several works on the history of the Anabaptists in various countries or on leading personalities in the move. Heberle wrote on Hans Denck (1851 and 1855) and Capito's relation to Swiss Anabaptism (1858), Thousand. Due east. Röhrich on Hans Denck (1853) and the Anabaptist movement in Strasbourg (1860), Chiliad. Keim on Ludwig Haetzer (1856), 1000. W. H. Hochhuth on the movement in Hesse (1858-1860), Friedrich Nippold on David Joris (1863-1868), and Chr. Meyer on the motion in Upper Swabia (1874). Later many individual biographies of Anabaptist leaders appeared; e.g., Denck (Keller 1862, Haake 1897, Schwindt 1922, Weis 1925, Coutts 1927, Vittali 1932); Haetzer (Weis 1930, Goeters 1956); David Joris (Bainton 1935); Grebel (Bender 1950); Blaurock (Jecklin 1891, Loserth 1898, Moore 1955); Hoffman (Leendertz 1883, zur Linden 1885); Hubmaier (Vedder 1905, Mau 1912, Sachsse 1914, Wiswedel 1939); Menno (Cramer 1837, Roosen 1848, Vos 1914, Horsch 1916, Krahn 1936).

Some excitement was caused past the inquiry done past archivist Ludwig Keller of Münster on the forerunners of the Anabaptists and by his attempt to prove direct connection between them and the old-evangelical parties of the Middle Ages. In his investigations he was led by the idea that the Anabaptists, in whom he recognized a revival of apostolic church life, must be the descendants of those suppressed brotherhoods, and he tried on a big scale to construct an unbroken chain of free evangelical brotherhoods from original Christianity to the nowadays. Fifty-fifty though this attempt failed, nevertheless his book, Dice Reformation und dice älteren Reformparteien (1885), retains its value by virtue of the source material it contains; it was a powerful incentive to further research on Anabaptist history in all countries in which congregations were formed during the Reformation. Fifty-fifty before this volume appeared, Ludwig Keller had published monographs on the Anabaptists, for the purpose of serving the truth. His presentation of the life of the Anabaptist leader Hans Denck (Ein Apostel der Wiedertäufer, 1882) won broad attention.

In the following years books and manufactures on the Anabaptists were published as follows: J. Habets on Maastricht (1877), J. Hansen on Aachen (1884), F. O. zur Linden on Melchior Hoffman (1885), Gustav Bossert on the Anabaptist motion in Württemberg (1888 ff.), C. Gerbert, in Strasbourg (1889), Karl Rembert, in the duchy of Jülich (1893 and 1899), A. H. Newman on the Anabaptist movement in the 16th century (1897), Joh. Loserth, in Styria (1894), Eduard Jacobs, in the Harz (1899), Friedrich Rotli, in Augsburg and Upper Swabia (1900), Eduard Becker, in Kürnbach (1902), Rudolf Wolkan on the hymns of the Anabaptists (1903) and the Hutterian Brethren in America (1918), Christian Hege on the Anabaptists in the Kurpfalz (1908), Paul Wappler, in Thuringia (1908 ff), Hermann Nestler, in Regensburg (1926), and Alt, in Kaufbeuren (1930).

The theology of the Anabaptists and their place in the history of Christian idea has received considerable attention in recent years. Ernst Troeltsch's Sociallehren der christlichen Kirchen und Gruppen (1912, English 1936) was epoch-making and influential for the typology of the Anabaptist movement. Johannes Kühn'south Toleranz und Offenbarung (1923) was a further creative and stimulating endeavour in this direction. Karl Holl, "Luther und die Schwärmer" (Gesammelte Aufsätze, 1922), and Ulrich Bergfried, Die Verantwortung als theologisches Problem im Täufertum des 16. Jahrhunderts (1938), while containing much valuable information, wrote wholly from the strict Lutheran standpoint with a negative disquisitional upshot, similar to H. Lüdemann'due south earlier Reformation und Täufertum (1896) from the Reformed standpoint. Fritz Heyer, Der Kirchenbegriff der Schwärmer (1939) was better only still misconceived the Anabaptist position. Walther Köhler, Dogmengeschichte als Geschichte des Christlichen Selbstbewusstseins, 2 Das Zeitalter der Reformation (1951) was the first general history of dogma to give the Anabaptists both infinite and a fair evaluation. F. Due west. Littell's The Anabaptist View of the Church building (1952) was by all odds the best monograph an Anabaptist theology produced past the 1950s. John Horsch'due south Babe Baptism and its Origin among Protestants (1917) treated a limited field thoroughly and was important for its assembly of documentary evidence for the emergent years of Anabaptism. Ethelbert Stauffer'southward important article "The Anabaptist Theology of Martyrdom" brilliantly opened a new aspect. H. S. Bough set forth the essence of the Anabaptist faith in The Anabaptist Vision (reprinted from Mennonite Quarterly Review 18, 1949). The Mennonite Quarterly Review's "Special Anabaptist Theology Number" (Jan 1950) independent valuable studies. J. C. Wenger published "The Theology of Pilgram Marpeck" (Mennonite Quarterly Review 12, 1938, 205-256). A later study was Peter Kawerau's Melchior Hofmann als religiöser Denver(1954).

Modern comprehensive accounts of Anabaptism through the mid-20th century, following the initial endeavour by Antje Brons in her Ursprung, Entwicklung und Schicksale (1884), were delivered only by English and American writers (except for the brief account in Horst Penner'due south Weltweite Bruderschaft of 1955). In English A. H. Newman's History of Anti-Pedobaptism . . . to 1609 (1897) was the first skilful account, and is yet useful. E. B. Bax, Rise and Autumn of the Anabaptists (1903), written from the social and socialistic point of view, did not go across Münster. E. C. Freeway, The Story of the Anabaptists (1904), was better but cursory. C. H. Smith's full general works on Mennonite history (1920 and 1941) gave the all-time comprehensive handling, although John Horsch'southward Mennonites in Europe (1942) gave more detail, and R. J. Smithson's The Anabaptists (1935) was a reliable popular business relationship. Roland Bainton's treatment of the Anabaptists in his Reformation of the Sixteenth Century (1952) was the best in any full general history of the Reformation or of the church as a whole. At last the truthful character of the Anabaptists was beingness reported by the best modern church historians, amongst whom the American Bainton was a peer. West. Wiswedel'south well-written and reliable essays on a large number of Anabaptist leaders and episodes in his three-book work, Bilder und Führergestalten aus dem Täufertum (1928, 1930, 1952), together with numerous manufactures in scholarly journals, stamped him as one of the best 20th century scholarly pop writers in Anabaptism. He wrote ex animo.

In prewar Austria the Hutterian Brethren had their history written by their ain chroniclers and distributed by means of copies. To the outside world the brotherhood was shut away for centuries. These valuable documents were published in extracts in 1883 by Josef Beck in book 43 of the Oesterreichische Geschichts-Quellen equally Geschichts-Bücher der Wiedertäufer. Finally the full publication of the large Geschicht-Buch was accomplished past Rudolf Wolkan in 1923 and A. J. F. Zieglschmid in 1943, followed by the Klein-Geschichtsbuch by Zieglschmid in 1947. The large Hutterian hymnbook had already been published in 1914; the fully edited scholarly edition by Zieglschmid (manuscript deposited in the Goshen Higher Library) awaited a publisher.

There had already been some articles published by Gregor Wolny on the Anabaptists in Moravia (1850) and past von Kripp on the Anabaptist movement in Tyrol (1857). The piece of work and collection of materials of Beck was followed by publications by Alexander Nicoladoni on Johannes Bünderlin (1888 and 1893), by Joseph Jäkel on the Anabaptist motility in Upper Austria (1889 and 1895), by the outstanding scholar Joh. Loserth on the Anabaptist movement in Tyrol (1892 and 1894), on Balthasar Hubmaier (1893), the Anabaptist movement in Moravia and Styria (1894), on the communism of the Hutterites in Moravia (1894), and on the movement in Lower Austria (1899), too numerous manufactures in the Mennonitisches Lexikon and in other periodicals. Loserth's work was of the highest quality. Worthy of mention were also the works by Hartmann Ammann on the Anabaptist motility in the Puster Valley (1896 and 1897), by Georg Loesche on Anabaptism and Protestantism in Tyrol and Vorarlberg (1926), by Robert Friedmann on the Habaner in Czechoslovakia (1927), by Lydia Müller on the communism of the Hutterian Brethren in Moravia (1927), past Fr. Hruby on the Anabaptists in Moravia (1935), by Franz Kalb on the move in the Wipptal (1951), and by Widmoser on Tyrolese Anabaptism (1951). John Horsch'southward Hutterian Brethren (1929) was the only proficient full general work on the Hutterites in English language.

A stately series of writings has likewise been produced in Switzerland, the land of Anabaptist origins. In addition to the studies by Füsslin, pioneer piece of work was done by Emil Egli on the Anabaptists in Zürich (1878) and in St. Gall (1887), and in his important collection of courtroom records regarding the history of the Swiss Reformation (Actensammlung zur Schweizerischen Reformationsgeschichte, 1879). Egli'southward research in the field of church building history yielded disclosures primal to the written report of Mennonite origins. After his decease Georg Finsler published (in 1910) the first volume of the history of the Swiss Reformation (1519-1525), which Egli had nigh completed. Here Egli's inquiry was unusually comprehensive, precisely on the Anabaptist movement. From the socio-economical viewpoint Ernst H. Correll threw light on Swiss Anabaptist-Mennonites (1925); his piece of work was the first thorough presentation of an Anabaptist group in the sociological sense. (See Historiography, Switzerland and Historiography, France)

On the Anabaptist motility in Italia the publications of Karl Benrath, Wiedertäufer im Venetianischen (1885) and Reformation in Venedig (1887), have been superseded by the work of Henry DeWind "Anabaptism and Italy" in Church History (1952), based on his unpublished doctoral dissertation at the Academy of Chicago, "Relations Between Italian Reformers and the Anabaptists in the Mid-Sixteenth Century" (1951). DeWind has shown that there was no true Anabaptist move in Italy, Benrath and Comba (I Nostri Protestante, 1897) having dislocated anti-Trinitarians with Anabaptists. (Run across Italy.)

Anabaptism in England volition receive full handling for the start fourth dimension in Irvin Horst's doctoral dissertation (Amsterdam, 1957).

The primary repository of scholarly manufactures on Anabaptist history, theology, etc., has been the Mennonite Quarterly Review, which since its founding in 1927 has published a vast corporeality of material in this field and sought to keep beside of current research. Significant articles accept appeared in Archiv für Reformationsgeschichte and in Church History.

Independent judgments on the Anabaptist movement were plant in few handbooks on church history. Ane of the start objective presentations was that by Max Goebel in his Geschichte des christlichen Lebens in der evangelischen rheinisch-westfälischen Kirche (1848). The most thorough evaluations were given by G. Müller in his Kirchengeschichte (2nd ed. 1922) and Möller-Kawerau in Lehrbuch der Kirchengeschichte (1907). Noteworthy articles appeared in Realencyclopedie für Protestantische Theologie and Kirche (3rd ed., 1896-1908), and in Dice Religion in Geschichte and Gegenwart (2d ed., 1926).

The historiography of Utopian likewise every bit scientific socialism likewise dealt with Anabaptism. This trend, represented especially by Kautsky (Vorläufer des neueren Sozialismus I, 1895) and Bernstein (d. 1932), had 2 objectives: (1) to explain the Reformation in general co-ordinate to the principles of materialistic historiography; (ii) to see especially in the Anabaptist movement the "forerunners of modern socialism." A critical summary of these attempts was given for the get-go time in Correll, Das schweizerische Täufermennonitentum (1925), p. 6 f.; come across also p. 16; meet likewise his sections "Allgemeine historisch-soziologische Kennzeichnung des Täufertums" and "Ausbreitung und ökonomisch-sozialer Charakter des Täufer-Mennonitentums" with historiographical remarks. Socialistic historiography has to its credit the recognition of the distinction betwixt radical and pacifist Anabaptists. Recently East German language writers exploited the Anabaptists for the Communist crusade; e.g., K. Kleinschmidt, Thomas Münzer (1952).

Finally the religio-sociological standard works by Ernst Troeltsch (Protestantisches Christentum und Kirche in der Neuzeit, 1909, and Die Soziallehren der christlichen Kirchen und Gruppen, 3rd ed. 1923, translated into English, The Social Teachings of the Christian Churches, Northward.Y., 1936) and Max Weber (Gesammelte Aufsätze zur Religionssoziologie I, 1920, and "Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft" in Grundriss der Sozialökonomie, 1922) accept removed the last trace of a sectarian judgment. To the aforementioned terminate Walther Köhler (1870-1946), the Zwingli scholar, worked in an eminently objective manner.

For a treatment of bibliographies see the article on this field of study in this Encyclopedia.

Source Publications. The years 1925-1955 have witnessed a significant amount of publication of major Anabaptist sources. The first such enterprise was the publication of two Marpeck writings, one, the Vermahnung edited by Christian Hege in the Gedenkschrift of 1925, the other the Verantwortung edited by Johann Loserth in 1929 (Quellen und Forsehungen zur Geschichte der oberdeutschen Taufgesinnten im xvi. Jahrhundert). Meanwhile the Verein für Reformationsgeschichte, led by Hans von Schubert and Otto Scheel, had undertaken the publication of all Anabaptist archival sources in the German language language surface area, under the series title, Quellen zur Geschichte der Wiedertäufer (changed to Täufer in 1951). The following volumes appeared before 1940: Herzogtum Württemberg 1930, Markgraftum Brandenburg (Bayern I) 1934, Glaubenszeugnisse oberdeutscher Taufgesinnter (Hutterite) 1938. After World State of war II, the Mennonitischer Geschichtsverein now beingness a partner in the project, the following boosted volumes appeared: Bayern II 1951, Baden-Pfalz 1951, Hans Denk's Works 1956. Further volumes were in preparation: Alsace I (Strasbourg), Glaubenszeugnisse Two, Württemberg II, Hutterite Epistles ii vols., Austria 3 vols., Rhineland ii vols.

The Täuferakten for Hesse (1527-1626) were also published in 1951 by the Historische Kommission für Hessen und Waldeck, and in 1952 Leonhard von Muralt began the publication of a Swiss Anabaptist source serial (Quellen zur Geschichte der Täufer in der Schweiz) with a volume on Zürich, to be followed past a volume containing the Berner Gespräch of 1538, and at to the lowest degree two other volumes.

The two swell Hutterite chronicles take been published, the outset in 2 editions (Wolkan, Vienna, 1923, and Zieglschmid, Philadelphia, 1943), the second, again by Zieglschmid, in 1947 at Philadelphia. Riedemann's Rechenschaft was reprinted twice (in 1903 at Scottdale, Pa., and in 1938 in England), so published in an English translation in England in 1949. The Mennonite Quarterly Review has published a series of English language translations of shorter documents and tracts by J. C. Wenger, such as the Schleitheim Confession. The American Series, The Christian Classics, published in 1956 one book on the Anabaptists and related groups.

There has been extensive use of the Anabaptist theme in literature, with the Münsterites used most oftentimes. Two doctoral dissertations surveyed this field up to 1913: W. Rauch, Johann von Leiden, der König von Sion, in der deutschen Dichtung (Leipzig, 1912), and H. Hermsen, Die Wiedertäufer zu Münster in der deutschen Dichtung (Stuttgart, 1913). Elizabeth H. Bender published a serial of manufactures on Anabaptists and Mennonites in German and American literature in the Mennonite Quarterly Review 1943-1946, and Mary East. Bender's doctoral dissertation (Indiana, 1957) surveyed the field since 1900.

The hymnology of the Anabaptists received an outstanding treatment by Rudolf Wolkan in his Dice Lieder der Wiedertäufer (Berlin, 1903). The great German hymnologist, Philipp Wackernagel, treated Anabaptist hymnology twice. His Lieder der niederländischen Reformierten aus der Zeit der Verfolgung im 16. Jahrhundert (Frankfurt, 1867) was largely devoted to Dutch Anabaptist hymns, reproducing a total of 79, while book III of his Das deutsche Kirchenlied (Leipzig, 1870) reprinted 45 hymns of German language Anabaptists (441-486). (Meet Hymnology)

The but comprehensive treatment of Anabaptist historiography to the 1950s was that by Christian Hege in his article Geschichtsschreibung in Mennonitisches Lexikon 2, 96-101, to which the present article is much indebted. -- HSB

1989 Update

More than one-half a century ago American historian Carl Becker observed that every generation must rewrite its own history. His dictum is illustrated nowhere more amply than in Anabaptist historiography of the by 25-30 years. A body of agog revisionists has staked out claims to fresh, stimulating interpretations. Other scholars, both non-Mennonite and Mennonite, have poked most in the nooks and crannies of Anabaptist life and thought, publishing a large number of dissertations, monographs, and articles, with not- Mennonites regaining the initiative that Bender and others had seized earlier for Mennonites.

The primary, but not exclusive, object of the revisionists has been the so-called "Bender school"-Harold South. Bender, Robert Friedmann, J. C. Wenger, to a bottom extent Cornelius Krahn, and some of their Mennonite students writing in the 1950s. The revisionists also challenged the work of Methodist Franklin Littell, some Baptist scholars (Davis, Estep), Swiss Reformed Fritz Blanke and Congregationalist-Unitarian George H. Williams. All of these latter authors themselves revised or extended the work of Bender and others, but were at 1 with him in the larger task of rescuing Anabaptists theologically from the dogmatic misinterpretations of traditionalist historiography. To Bender and his colleagues, Anabaptists were voluntaristic in religious selection (and therefore insisted upon believers' baptism for adults), advocates of a church completely free from land influence, biblical literalists, nonparticipants in any government action to avoid moral compromise, suffering retainer disciples of Jesus who emphasized moral living and who were persecuted and martyred as Jesus had been, and restitutionists who tried to restore pre-Constantinian Christian primitivism, etc.

Bender and Friedmann themselves had been cocky-conscious revisionists, using theology and a normative mode of inquiry to justify the Anabaptist movement in the calorie-free of four centuries of defamation in the name of confessional rectitude (Kurtz, for example). Lutherans Karl Müller and Karl Holl, among others, revived confessionalism within Reformation scholarship, Holl equally it practical to the Schwärmer including the Anabaptists. Manifestly Bender and his colleagues thought the obvious retort needed to be couched in confessional terms in guild to notice credence in the scholarly globe, or even to make both Anabaptists and later Mennonites theologically respectable. This nascent Mennonite historiography created in issue a free church confessionalism with orthopraxis replacing orthodoxy, ironical in that the Anabaptists detested confessionalism, and "free church building confessionalism" is a contradiction in terms. The "Bender schoolhouse" used contemporary historical methodology, pioneered for Anabaptism by Carl Cornelius and others, utilizing principal sources based on views of the Anabaptists straight expressed instead of 16th-century polemics composed by their bitter enemies. That methodology received the beatitude of secular scholars. The Bender school's search for essence, for that mentalité that somehow characterized all Anabaptists worthy of the proper noun, coincided with Western historians' then-current passion for finding essence and emphasizing synthesis as confronting describing diversity and analyzing particularity. (Renaissance scholars were wrestling with the essence of that movement when Bender put forward his atypical Anabaptist Vision; he suited the historiographical mood of his times.) Merely Bender's fresh synthesis of Anabaptism was also idealistic, too nice, almost likewise sweet despite its cantankerous theology and bitter Christ; it invited revision.

What was revised, by whom? Here follow some of the more significant areas of revision:

(1) Scholars rehabilitated Melchior Hoffman as a bonafide Anabaptist, ane whose influence was paramount for Dutch Anabaptists and widely pervasive in other regions (Deppermann; Deppermann, Packull, Stayer; Krahn, 1964; Voolstra). Hoffman's reappearance coincided with a broader return to a vital Anabaptist spirituality (Klaassen 1960, 1963; Seebaß 1972; Packull, 1977; Oosterbaan, 1977; Ozment; Erb) as confronting a narrow biblicism-only interpretation used by Bender to counter Holl. More recently scholars have rescued Hoffman'south disciple David Joris from near oblivion, casting his movement as a viable option to that of Menno's followers and interpreting his spiritualism as a gradual evolution (Zijlstra; Stayer, 1984, 1985; Waite). Scholars have also tended to see more clearly the Hoffman legacy in the life and work of Menno (Voolstra; Bornhäuser).

(2) Some revisionists reexamined the Anabaptism of Münster, viewing it as theologically viable under Bernhard Rothmann with adherents from middle and artisan classes joining voluntarily not because of intolerable pressure, and established deliberately as the regnant religious blueprint past a duly elected metropolis quango of its own gratuitous will--not under duress (Kirchhoff 1970, 1973; Jahrbuch für Westfälische KirchenGeschichte, 78 [Oct. 1985], unabridged result; Stayer 1986; many others). Kirchhoff's discovery of indigenous upper- and lower-middle grade origins, coupled with Peachey's earlier piece of work on social class origins of Swiss Anabaptists, provided impetus for a growing rejection of the older theory that Anabaptists were initially entirely of lower form origin.

(3) Gottfried Seebaß (1972) restored Hans Hut and his strain of mystical-apocalyptical thought to the fold of legitimate Anabaptists. South German Anabaptism became more unique and varied, drawing from Hut equally well as Denck, distinctly different from the Swiss Brethren variety (Packull, 1977).

(4) Pocket-sized wonder that Anabaptist particularity, specially in origins (Deppermann, Stayer, Packull, 1975) but likewise in character, began to boss historiography. Some scholars thought that Williams (1962) had not demarcated his three Anabaptist hearths (Zürich, Nürnberg, Amsterdam) sharply enough, though as an independent scholar Williams' position on iii singled-out places of Anabaptist origins seemed clear.

(5) Led by Clasen (1972) and paralleling broader 16th-century studies, scholars began to examine more carefully the broadest possible social conditions of Anabaptists. They probed especially the radical social and economic, as against exclusively theological or eccelesial, roots of Anabaptism, and laid bare a motility built upon a vigorous protestation against lower class living weather condition, taking event with Clasen on this bespeak (Goeters; Seebaß, 1972, 1974; Stayer, 1975; Haas; Mellink, 1978, 1979; Goertz, 1979, 1980, 1985, 1987).

(6) Marxist historians, peculiarly those from the German Autonomous Commonwealth, while retaining their interest in and affection for social revolutionary Thomas Müntzer, have increasingly seen Anabaptists and other radical reformers as motivated essentially by religion. And they have helped Western historians to recognize the significance of economic and social class struggles in these movements (Zschäbitz; Hoyer; Laube; Looss; Vogler).

(vii) With regard to Anabaptist nonresistance, Stayer (1972) wrote one of the almost thoroughly researched studies of Anabaptists in the past 25 years, focusing on the Anabaptist biblically defenseless position (Bauman) but also on those who used the sword or dedicated its use by Christians. He solidified and profoundly expanded the before, geographically more than narrowly restricted, studies of non-pacifist Anabaptists by Yoder (1959, 1962-68), Klaassen (1960), and Oyer (1964).

(8) When did Anabaptism brainstorm: 21 January 1525, in Zürich with the outset believers' baptisms, or late in Feb 1527 at Schleitheim? The latter has been proposed as the fourth dimension and identify of origin because the "Brotherly Union" (Schleitheim Confession) established the separatist--or sectarian-character of Anabaptism (Yoder, 1972; Deppermann, Packull, Stayer; Snyder, 1984-I).

(9) Some interpreters focused on several Anabaptist leaders who projected a commanding personal charisma, particularly when they preached the imminent return of Christ--preeminently Hut and Hoffman. This emphasis was all the more necessary to showtime an exclusive moderate biblicism of the earlier scholars (Seebaß, 1972; Packull, 1977; Deppermann; Davis, 1979).

(x) Medieval antecedents of Anabaptism, if not medieval forerunners, came into vogue again. Influence may well have emanated from the Brethren of the Mutual Life, perhaps the Hussites, some forms of monasticism--but no ane quite repeated Ritschl's theory of Franciscan Tertiaries as forerunners (Davis, 1974; Zeman, 1976; Packull, 1977; Snyder, 1984-I, 1987; Erb; Martin, 1986, 1988).

(11) Hubmaier again entered center phase, based upon his obvious commanding theological influence even on those who disliked him (perhaps Sattler; certainly the Hutterites): theology of baptism, soteriology, complimentary will among others (Yoder, 1959; Armour; Bergsten; Windhorst; Liland).

(12) Scholars have reasserted the subtle only vital influence of Erasmus and other humanists on Anabaptists, refuting primarily Bough (Friedmann always idea in that location was a connection, but out of respect for Bender he never declared himself in public on the point; come across works by Robert Kreider; Horst, 1967; Burger; Augustijn, 1986; Schrag).

(thirteen) About recently scholars have raised basic questions about the role and significance of women amidst the Anabaptists, challenging scholarly negligence every bit well as prior assertions about Anabaptist egalitarianism. More recent students have suggested that the Anabaptists did not heighten the status or widen the range of permissible activities of women, specially in religious affairs, beyond the subordinate role established past Protestants (Bainton, 1971; Irwin, 1979, 1982; John Klassen; Marr; Umble; Kobelt-Groch).

Although revisionism angry the livelier interest and debate amongst students of Anabaptism, scholars published many other studies of high merit that were not revisionist either in intent or influence. Some tin be clustered around meaning themes or persons; others are less amenable to organizational patterns. Hither follow some observations about a selected few.

(1) Two studies deserve special mention considering of their authors' mastery of massive amounts of sources: Williams (1962) and Clasen (1972, 1978 for data). Each author in his own way compelled all scholars of Anabaptism to wrestle with either his synthesis or his nuanced theses and interpretations, Williams on theology and morphology, Clasen on social history. Williams' piece of work was brilliant. So also was Clasen'southward, despite Mennonite scholars' neglect of him; scholars volition find themselves returning repeatedly to mine its richer lodes.

(2) A spate of studies probed Anabaptism in person or region or past topic, a few of them spawned past Bough'south own enthusiasm for farming out topics for "definitive" treatment (Armour; Balke; Bauman; Beachy; Bergsten; Bornhäuser; Dalzell; Davis, 1974; Gingerich; Gismann-Fiel; Gross; Hillerbrand, 1962; Horst, 1972; Jecker; Keeney; Peter Klassen; William Klassen; Oyer, 1964; Packull, 1977; Pater; Plümper; Rempel; Schäufele; Schlabach; Snyder, 1984-I; Voolstra; de Vries; Windhorst; Yoder, 1962-68; Zeman, 1969).

(3) Some scholars returned to the part of martyrs and their influence on survivors and on the temperament of the entire movement. For instances, was there a discernable martyr theology as Stauffer had claimed (Alan Kreider; Doerksen; Dyck; John Klassen; Umble)?

(4) Students of Marpeck take come into their ain, elevating him to his proper formative role because of the wide influence of his mature theological synthesis (William Klassen; Blough, 1984, 1987; Boyd).

(v) Fresh research on Menno led many scholars to reevaluate his views on the incarnation (Christology), the church, soteriology (conservancy), hermeneutics (biblical estimation), the ban, the quality and sophistication of his theology, as well as his ability to handle several languages including Latin (Oosterbaan, 1961; Meihuizen; Poetteker; Keeney; Bornhäuser; Irwin, 1978; Voolstra; Klaassen, 1986; Augustijn, 1987).

(half dozen) Scores of scholars treated Anabaptist hermeneutics at least tangentially, then directly in several studies of significance (Klaassen, William Klassen, and Poetteker, entire issue of Mennonite Quarterly Review 41 [Apr 1966], in addition to the dissertations of Klassen and Poettcker; Yoder, 1967; Dyck, 1978).

(7) Italian scholars reassessed Italian Anabaptism, reaffirmed the antitrinitarian cadre merely fitted it more deeply within general Anabaptism than earlier scholars had done. Stella utilized fresh archival sources, tied the movement more than closely to Neapolitan spiritualism, peculiarly Juan de Valdes, only also to the Marranos (Stella, 1967, 1969; Williams, 1972; Rotondò).

(8) What differences existed, conscious or not, between North German language and Southward German language Anabaptists? (Deppermann; Oyer, 1984).

(nine) Liberation theology. Scholars and churchmen alike have applied Anabaptist protests to present-twenty-four hour period conditions of oppression confronting the lower form, especially outside Europe and North America (Rutschman; MQR, (August 1984), entire issue; Arnold Snyder, 1984-II).

One might suppose that afterwards the alterations of many revisionists, and under the influence of dozens of additional scholars irresolute before views of Anabaptism, no synthesis remains, nor is it possible to shape i. If the scholar concentrates on differences among Anabaptists, the multifaceted nature of the movement emerges almost conspicuously, so that the word Anabaptism is in some sense a misnomer. But if she asks how the Anabaptists differed from item Protestant Reformers or from Catholics, a discernible core of Anabaptist idea and practice does indeed emerge, or remain. Within the sweep of church history it is more remarkable that a large majority of Anabaptists espoused and practiced biblical nonresistance than that a minority did not; Christianity has been a faith that glorified warriors. Or, Bender's (and Kühn'southward earlier him) discipleship motif, based largely on the study of Swiss Brethren, describes surprisingly well the first-generation Anabaptists in Central Frg or the netherlands or Austria, even those whose dominant early religiosities were more mystical than biblicist. Why? Non because Anabaptists from unlike geographical regions regularly conferred with each other and hammered out agreements. Morphology and broad synthesis are in ill repute at the moment, but they may well render to some prominence when scholars tire of fragmentation in our nowadays mood of examining particularity and again crave the kind of meaning institute simply in generality or synthesis more broadly bandage (Packull, 1979; Williams, 1984; Dyck, 1984; Weaver, 1985, 1987).

The historiography of Anabaptism is an inexhaustible topic. Only a few of the many strands of historiography of the by 25 years can exist touched in one article, and only a few representative samples of significant scholarly works tin be included in the bibliography. In fact the latter has been shaped consciously to fit the former. Past design this study has not covered the publication of sources or of commonage works--essays from symposia, festschriften--omissions of fabric so important that the commodity suffers in its usefulness to many readers. Merely some limitations had to exist set. -- JSO

Bibliography

Armour, Rollin Due south. Anabaptist Baptism. Scottdale, PA: Herald Printing, 1966.

Augustijn, Cornelis. "Erasmus and Menno Simons," Mennonite Quarterly Review 60 (1986): 497-508.

Augustijn, Cornelis. "Der Epilog von Menno Simons' 'Meditation,' 1539," in Anabaptistes et dissidents au XVIe siècle, Jean-Georges Rott and Simon Fifty. Verheus. Baden- Baden: Koerner, 1987: 175-88.

Bainton, Roland H. Women of the Reformation in Deutschland and Italia. Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing Business firm, 1971: 145-58.

Balke, Willem. Calvijn en de Doperse radikalen. Amsterdam: Ton Rolland, 1973.

Bauman, Clarence. Gewaltlosigkeit im Täufertum. Leiden: Brill, 1968.

Beachy, Alvin J. The Concept of Grace in the Radical Reformation. Nieuwkoop: De Graaf, 1977.

Bender, Harold S. "Anabaptist Vision." Church History 13 (1944): 3-24, reprinted in Mennonite Quarterly Review eighteen (1944): 67-88.

Bender, Harold S. Conrad Grebel, 1498-1526. Goshen, IN: Mennonite Historical Society, 1950.

Bergsten, Torsten. Balthasar Hubmaier-Seine Stellung zu Reformation und Täufertum. Kassel: Oncken, 1961.

Blanke, Fritz. Brüder in Christo. Zürich: Zwingli Verlag [1955]; English language trans. 1961.

Blough, Neal. Christologie Anabaptiste: Pilgram Marpeck et 50'humanité du Christ. [Geneva]: Labor et Fides, 1984.

Blough, Neal. "Pilgram Marpeck, Martin Luther and the Humanity of Christ." Mennonite Quarterly Review 61 (1987): 203-12.

Bornhäuser, Christoph. Leben und Lehre Menno Simons'. Neukirchen/Vluyn: Neukirchener Verlag, 1973.

Boyd, Stephen B. "Pilgram Marpeck and the Justice of Christ." PhD diss., Harvard Divinity School, 1984.

Burger, Edward 1000. Erasmus and the Anabaptists. PhD diss., U. of California at Santa Barbara, 1977.

Clasen, Claus-Peter. Anabaptism: A Social History, 1525-1618. Ithaca: Cornell U. Press, 1972.

Clasen, Claus-Peter. The Anabaptists in Due south and Key Germany, Switzerland and Austria. Goshen, IN: Mennonite Quarterly Review, 1978.

Cornelius, Carl A. Geschichte des Münsterischen Aufruhrs, 2 vols. Leipzig: Weigel, 1855-1860.

Dalzell, Timothy. "The Anabaptist Purity of Life Ethic." PhD diss., North Texas State U., 1985.

David, Kenneth R. Anabaptism and Asceticism: A Written report in Intellectual Origins. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1974.

Davis, Kenneth R. "Anabaptism equally a Charismatic Movement." Mennonite Quarterly Review 53 (1979): 219-34.

Deppermann, Klaus. Melchior Hoffman: Soziale Unruhen und apokalyptische Visionen im Zeitalter der Reformation. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck und Ruprecht, 1979; English translation, Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark, 1987.

Deppermann, Klaus, Werner O. Packull, James One thousand. Stayer. "From Monogenesis to Polygenesis: The Historical Give-and-take of Anabaptist Origins." Mennonite Quarterly Review 49 (1975): 83-121.

Doerksen, Victor 1000. "The Anabaptist Martyr Carol." Mennonite Quarterly Review 51 (1977): v-21.

Dyck, Cornelius J. "Hans de Ries, Theologian and Churchman: A Written report in Second Generation Anabaptism." PhD diss., U. of Chicago, 1962.

Dyck, Cornelius J. "Hermeneutics and Discipleship " in De Geest in het geding, ed. I. B. Horst and others. Alpen: Rjeenk Willink, 197: 57-72.

Dyck, Cornelius J. "The Anabaptist Agreement of the Good News," in Anabaptism and Mission, ed. Wilbert R. Shenk. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1984: 24-39.

Dyck, Cornelius J. "The Suffering Church in Anabaptism." Mennonite Quarterly Review 59 (1985): 5-23.

Erb, Peter C. "Anabaptist Spirituality," in Protestant Spiritual Traditions, ed. Frank C. Senn. New York: Paulist, 1986: fourscore-124.

Estep, William R. The Anabaptist Story. Nashville: Broadman Press, 1963; rev. ed. One thousand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1975.

Fast, Heinold. "Die Sonderstellung der Täufer in St. Gallen und Appenzell." Zwingliana xi (1960): 223-forty.

Fast, Heinold. "Europäische Forschungen auf dem Gebiet der Täufer-und Mennonitengeschichte (1962- 1967)." Mennonitische Geschichtsblätter 24 (1967): nineteen-xxx.

Friedmann, Robert. Hutterite Studies, ed. Harold S. Bender. Goshen, IN: Mennonite Historical Society, 1961.

Friedmann, Robert. The Theology of Anabaptism. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1973.

Gastaldi, Ugo. Storia dell'anabattismo, 2 vols. Torino: Claudiana, 1972, 1981.

Gingerich, Ray C. "The Mission Impulse of Early Swiss and S-High german-Austrian Anabaptism." PhD diss., Vanderbilt U., 1980.

Gismann-Fel, Hildegund. Das Täufertum in Vorarlberg. Dornbirn: Vorarlberger Verlagsanstalt, 1982.

Goertz, Hans-Jürgen Goertz, ed. Umstrittenes Täufertum, 1525-1975: Neue Forschungen. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck und Ruprecht, 1975, 1977.

Goertz, Hans-Jürgen Goertz, ed. Radikale Reformatoren: 21 Biographische Skizzen von Thomas Müntzer bis Paracelsus. Munich: Beck, 1978.

Goertz, Hans-Jürgen Goertz,. "History and Theology: A Major Problem of Anabaptist Enquiry Today." part of "Problems of Anabaptist History: A Symposium, with replies of six scholars: Carter Lindberg, John S. Oyer, William Klassen, Kenneth R. Davis, Werner O. Packull, and James One thousand. Stayer, in Mennonite Quarterly Review 53 (1979): 175-218.

Goertz, Hans-Jürgen Goertz. Dice Täufer: Geschichte und Deutung. Munich: Beck, 1980.

Goertz, Hans-Jürgen Goertz, "Das Täufertum--ein Weg in die Moderne?" in Zwingli und Europa: Referate und Protokoll des Internationalen Kongresses aus Anlass des 500. Geburtstages von Huldrych Zwingli, ed. Peter Blickle and others. Zürich: Vandenhoeck und Ruprecht, 1985: 165-81.

Goertz, Hans-Jürgen Goertz. "Aufständische Bauern und Täufer in der Schweiz," in Bauern und Reformation, ed. Peter Blickle and Peter Bierbrauer (Hamburg: Chronos, 1987), 1, 267-89.

Goeters, J. F. Gerhard. "Die Vorgeschichte des Täufertums in Zürich," in Studien zur Geschichte und Theologie der Reformation: Festschrift für Ernst Bizer, ed. Luise Abramowski and J. F. K. Goeters. Neukirchen/Vluyn: Neukirchener Verlag, 1969: 239-81.

Gross, Leonard. The Golden Years of the Hutterites. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1980.

Haas, Martin. "Der Weg der Täufer in die Absonderung: Zur Interdependenz von Theologie und sozialem Verhalten," in Umstrittenes Täufertum, 1525-1975: Neue Forschungen. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck und Ruprecht, 1975, 1977: 50-78.

Hillerbrand, Hans J. Die politische Ethik des oberdeutschen Täufertums: eine Untersuchung zur Religions- und Geistesgeschichte des Reformationszeitalters. Leiden: Brill, 1962.

Hillerbrand, Hans J. A Bibliography of Anabaptism, 1525-1620. Elkhart, IN: IMS 1962.

Hillerbrand, Hans J. "Die neuere Täuferforschung." Evangelische Theologie xiii (1968): 95-110.

Hillerbrand, Hans J., ed. The Radical Reformation: Divergent Interpretations. St. Louis: Sixteenth-Century Studies Conference, 1988.

Holl, Karl. "Luther und dice Schwärmer," in Holl, Gesammelte Aufsätze zur Kirchengeschichte, I: Luther. Tübingen: Mohr, 1923: 420-67.

Horst, Irvin B. Erasmus, the Anabaptists and the Trouble of Religious Unity. Haarlem: Tjeenk Willink, 1967.

Horst, Irvin B. The Radical Brethren: Anabaptism and the English language Reformation to 1558. Nieuwkoop: de Graaf, 1972.

Hoyer, Siegfried. "Lay Preaching and Radicalism in the Early Reformation." in Hillerbrand, Hans J., ed. The Radical Reformation: Divergent Interpretations. St. Louis: Sixteenth-Century Studies Briefing, 1988.

Irwin, Joyce L. "Embyrology and the Incarnation: A Sixteenth Century Debate." Sixteenth Century Journal 9, no. iii (1978): 93-104.

Irwin, Joyce Fifty. Womanhood in Radical Protestantism 1525-1675. New York: Mellen, 1979.

Irwin, Joyce L. "Society and the Sexes," in Reformation Europe: A Guide to Research, ed. Steven Ozment. St. Louis: Heart for Reformation Enquiry, 1982: 343-sixty.

Jecker, Hanspeter. Dice Basler Täufer: Studien zur Vor--und Frühgeschichte. Basel: Historische Gesellschaft, 1980.

Keeney, William E. Dutch Anabaptist Thought and Practise 1539-1564. Nieuwkoop: De Graaf, 1968.

Kirchhoff, Karl-Heinz. "Was There a Peaceful Anabaptist Congregation in Münster in 1534?" Mennonite Quarterly Review 44 (1970): 357-70.

Kirchhoff, Karl-Heinz. Die Täufer in Münster 1534-1535: Untersuchungen zum Umfang und zur Sozialstruktur der Bewegung. Münster: Aschendorff, 1973.

Klaassen, Walter. "Word, Spirit and Scripture in Early Anabaptist Idea." DPhil diss., Oxford U., 1960.

Klaassen, Walter. "Spiritualization in the Reformation." Mennonite Quarterly Review 37 (1963): 67-77.

Klaassen, Walter. Anabaptism Neither Catholic nor Protestant. Waterloo: Conrad Press, 1973.

Klaassen, Walter. "Menno Simons Inquiry, 1937-1986." Mennonite Quarterly Review 60 (1986): 483-96.

Klassen, John. "Women and the Family Among Dutch Anabaptist Martyrs." Mennonite Quarterly Review lx (1986): 548-71.

Klassen, Peter J. The Economics of Anabaptism, 1525-1560. London: Mouton, 1964.

Klassen, William. Covenant and Customs. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1968.

Kobelt-Groch, Marion. "Why Did Petronella Get out Her Hubby." Mennonite Quarterly Review 62 (1988): 26-41.

Krahn, Cornelius. Menno Simons Lebenswerk. Amsterdam: Gleijsteen, 1937.

Krahn, Cornelius. Dutch Anabaptism Origin, Spread, Life and Thought, 1450-1600. The Hague: Nijhoff, 1964.

Kreider, Alan F. "'The Servant is Not Greater Than His Master': Anabaptists and the Suffering Church building." Mennonite Quarterly Review 58 (1984): five-29.

Kreider, Robert S. "Anabaptism and Humanism: An Inquiry into the Relationship of Humanism to the Evangelical Anabaptists." Mennonite Quarterly Review 26 (1952): 123-41.

Kurtz, Johann. Lehrbuch der Kirchengeschichte für Studierende, 9th ed. Leipzig: Neumann, 1885: esp. 148-56.

Laube, Adolf. "Radicalism in the Reformation: A Enquiry Problem for Scholarship in Hillerbrand, Hans J., ed. The Radical Reformation: Divergent Interpretations. St. Louis: Sixteenth-Century Studies Conference, 1988.

Liechty, Daniel C. Andreas Fischer and the Sabbatarian Anabaptists. Scottdale, PA: Herald Printing, 1988.

Liland, Peder K. I. "Anabaptist Separatism: A Historical and Theological Study of the Contribution of Balthasar Hubmaier." PhD diss., Boston College, 1983.

Littell, Franklin H. The Anabaptist View of the Church. Hartford: American Lodge of Church History, 1952, reprinted every bit The Origins of Sectarian Protestantism. New York: Macmillan, 1964.

Looss, Siegrid. "Andreas Carlstadt," in Hillerbrand, Hans J., ed. The Radical Reformation: Divergent Interpretations. St. Louis: Sixteenth-Century Studies Conference, 1988.

Marr, M. Lucille. "Anabaptist Women of the N: Peers in the Faith, Subordinates in Wedlock." Mennonite Quarterly Review 61 (1987): 347-62.

Martin, Dennis D. "Monks, Mendicants and Anabaptists: Michael Sattler and the Benedictines Reconsidered." Mennonite Quarterly Review 60 (1986): 139-64.

Martin, Dennis D. "Catholic Spirituality and Anabaptist and Mennonite Discipleship." Mennonite Quarterly Review 62 (1988): v-25.

Mellink, Albert F. Amsterdam en de Wederdopers in de zestiende Eeuw. Nijmegen: Socialistiese Uitgeverij, 1978.

Mellink, Albert F. De radikale Reformatie als Thema van social-religieuze Geschiedenis. Nijmegen: Socialistiese Uitgeverij, 1979.

Meihuizen, H. W. Menno Simons: Ijveraar voor het Herstel van de nieuwtestamentische Gemeente. Haarlem: Tjeenk Willink, 1961.

Müller, Karl. Kirchengeschichte, 2 vols. Tübingen: Mohr, 1905-1919.

Müller, Karl. Luther u. Karlstadt. Tübingen: Mohr, 1907.

Oosterbaan, J. A. "The Theology of Menno Simons." Mennonite Quarterly Review 35 (1961): 187-96.

Oosterbaan, J. A. "The Reformation of the Reformation: Fundamentals of Anabaptist Theology." Mennonite Quarterly Review 51 (1977): 171-95, cf. Doopsgezinde. Bijdragen, north.r. 2 (1976): 36- 61.

Oyer, John S. Lutheran Reformers confronting Anabaptists: Luther, Melanchthon and Menius and the Anabaptists of Cardinal Deutschland. The Hague: Nijhoff, 1964.

Oyer, John S. "The Strasbourg Conferences of the Anabaptists, 1554-1607." Mennonite Quarterly Review 58 (1984): 218-29.

Ozment, Steven. Mysticism and Dissent: Religious Credo and Social Protest in the Sixteenth Century. New Haven: Yale U. Press, 1973.

Packull, Werner O. Mysticism and the Early South German-Austrian Anabaptist Movement, 1525-1531. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1977.

Packull, Werner O. "Some Reflections on the State of Anabaptist History: the Demise of a Normative Vision." Studies in Religion 8 (1979): 313-23.

Pater, Calvin A. Karlstadt as the Father of the Baptist Movements. Toronto: U. of Toronto Press, 1984.

Peachey, Paul. Die soziale Herkunft der Schweizer Täufer in der Reformationszeit, 1525-1540. Karlsruhe: Schneider, 1954.

Plümper, Hans-Dieter. Dice Gütergemeinschaft bei den Täufern des 16. Jahrhunderts. Göppingen: Kümmerle, 1972.

Poettcker, Henry. "The Hermeneutics of Menno Simons." ThD diss., Princeton Theological Seminary, 1961.

Rempel, John D. "Christology and the Lord's Supper in Anabaptism: A Study in the Theology of Balthasar Hubmaier, Pilgram Marpeck, and Dirk Philips." ThD diss., U. of Toronto, 1986.

Rotondò, Antonio. Studi eastward ricerche di storia ereticale italiana del Cinquecento. Torino: Giappiehelli, 1974.

Rutschuran, LaVerne. "Anabaptism and Liberation Theology." Mennonite Quarterly Review 55 (1981): 255-70.

Schäufele, Wolfgang. Das missionarische Bewußtsein und Wirken der Täufer. Neukirchen/Vluvn: Neukirchener Verlag, 1966.

Schlabach, Ervin. "The Dominion of Christ Amongst the Early Swiss Anabaptists." ThD diss., Chicago Theological Seminary, 1977.

Schrag, Dale. "Erasmian Origins of Anabaptist Pacifism: A Case Written report in Humanism and the Radical Reformation." MA thesis, Wichita State U., 1984.

Seebaß, Gottfried. "Müntzers Erbe: Werk, Leben und Theologie des Hans Hut." Unpublished Habilitations dissertation, Erlangen, 1972.

Seebaß, Gottfried. Bauernkrieg und Täufertum in Franken," Zeitschrift für Kirchengeschichte 85

(1974): 284-300.

Snyder, C. Arnold. The Life and Thought of Michael Sattler. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1984-ane.

Snyder, C. Arnold. "The Relevance of Anabaptist Nonviolence for Nicaragua Today." Conrad Grebel Review 2 (1984-Two): 123-38.

Snyder, C. Arnold. "Michael Satter, Benedictine: Dennis Martin's Objections Reconsidered." Mennonite Quarterly Review 61 (1987), 262-79.

Stayer, James M. Anabaptists and the Sword. Lawrence, KS: Coronado Press, 1972, 1976.

Stayer, James 1000. "Dice Anfänge des schweizerischen Taufertums im reformierten Kongregationalismus." in Goertz, Hans-Jürgen Goertz, ed. Umstrittenes Täufertum, 1525-1975: Neue Forschungen. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck und Ruprecht, 1975, 1977: nineteen-49.

Stayer, James Chiliad. "The Anabaptists." in Reformation Europe : a Guide to Inquiry, ed., Steven Ozment. St. Louis: Center for Reformation Research, 1982: 135-59.

Stayer, James M. "Davidite vs. Mennonite." Mennonite Quarterly Review 58 (1984): 459-76.

Stayer, James M. "David Joris: A Prolegomenon to Further Research." Mennonite Quarterly Review 59 (1985) 350-61.

Stayder, James M. "Was Dr. Kuehler's Conception of Early Dutch Anabaptism Historically Sound? The Historical Word of Münster 450 Years Later." Mennonite Quarterly Review threescore (1986): 261-88.

Stella, Aldo. Dall'anabattismo al socinianesimo net Cinquecento reneto: Ricerche storiche. Padua: Livania, 1967.

Stella, Aldo. Anabattismo due east antitrinitarismo in Italy internet 16 secolo: Nuove ricerche storiche. Padua: Livania, 1969.

Uhland, Friedwart. "Täufertum u. Obrigkeit in Augsburg im 16. Jahrhundert." PhD diss., U. of Tübingen, 1972.

Umble, Jenifer Hiett. "Women and Selection: An Test of the Martyrs Mirror." Master'southward thesis, Southern Methodist U., 1987.

Vogler, Günther. "The Anabaptist Kingdom of Münster in the Setting, of Imperial Politics," in Hillerbrand, Hans J., ed. The Radical Reformation: Divergent Interpretations. St. Louis: Sixteenth-Century Studies Conference, 1988.

Voolstra, Sjouke. Het Woord is Vlees Geworden: De Melchioritisch-Menniste Incarnatieleer. Kampen: Kok, [1982].

Vries, O. H. de. Leer en Praxis van de vroege Dopers. Leeuwarden: Dykstra, 1982.

Waite, Gary K. "Spiritualizing the Crusade: David Joris in the Context of the Early Reform and Anabaptist Movements in the Netherlands." PhD diss., U.. of Waterloo, 1986.

Weaver, J. Denny. "The Work of Christ: On the Difficulty of Identifying an Anabaptist Perspective."

Mennonite Quarterly Review 59 (1985): 107-29.

Weaver, J. Denny. Becoming Anabaptist: The Origin and Significance of Sixteenth-Century Anabaptism. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1987.

Wenger, J. C. Even Unto Death. Richmond, VA: John Knox Printing, 1961.

Wenger, J. C. "Doctrinal Position of the Swiss Brethren equally Revealed in Their Polemical

Tracts." Mennonite Quarterly Review 24 (1950): 65-72.

Williams, George H. The Radical Reformation. Philadelphia: Fortress Printing, 1962,

revised substantially with responses to specific revisionist critiques, as La Reforma Radical, trans. Antonio Alatorre. Naucalpan, Mexico: Fondo de Cultura Economica, 1984.

Williams, George H. "Two Social Strands in Italian Anabaptism, ca. 1550." in The Social history of the Reformation, ed. Lawrence P. Buck and Jonathan W. Zophy. Columbus: Ohio State U.

Printing, 1972: 156-207.

Williams, George H. "The Radical Reformation Revisited." Spousal relationship Seminary Quarterly Review 39 (1984): 1-24.

Windhorst, Christoph. Täuferisches Taufverständnis: Balthasar Hubmaiers Lehre zwischen traditioneller and reformatorischer Theologie. Leiden: Brill, 1976.

Yoder, John H. "The Turning Indicate in the Zwinglian Reformation." Mennonite Quarterly Review 32 (1958): 128-40.

Yoder, John H. "Balthasar Hubmaier and the Beginnings of Swiss Anabaptism." Mennonite Quarterly Review 33 (1959): 5-17.

Yoder, John H. Täufertum and Reformation im Gespräch: Dogmengeschichtliche Untersuchung der frühen Gespräche zwischen Schweizerischen Taäufer and Reformatoren, 2 vols. Weierhof: Menn. Geschichtsverein, and Zurich: EVZ Verlag, 1962, 1968.

Yoder, John H. "The Hermeneutics of the Anabaptists." Mennonite Quarterly Review 41 (1967): 291-308.

Yoder, John H. "Der Kristallisationspunkt des Täufertums." Mennonitische Geschblätter Jg. 29, north.F.

24 (1972): 35-47.

Yoder, John H., trans. and ed., The Legacy of Michael Sattler. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1973.

Zeman, Jarold. The Anabaptists and the Czech Brethren in Moravia 1526-1628: A Study of Origins and Contacts. The Hague: Nijhoff, 1969.

Zeman, Jarold. "Anabaptism: A Replay of Medieval Themes or a Prelude to the Mod Age?" Mennonite Quarterly Review 50 (1976): 259-71.

Zijlstra, S. Nicolaas Meyndertsz van Blesdijk: Een Bijdrage tot de Geschiedenis van bet Davidjorisme. Assen:Van Gorcum, 1983.

Zschäbitz, Gerhard. Zur mitteldeutschen Wiedertäuferbewegung nach dem grossen Bauernkrieg. Berlin: Rütten and Loening, 1958.

Writer(s)	Harold Southward. Bender
	John S. Oyer
Date Published	1989

Cite This Article

MLA mode

Bender, Harold S. and John South. Oyer. "Historiography: Anabaptist." Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. 1989. Spider web. 21 Apr 2022. https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Historiography:_Anabaptist&oldid=166257.

APA style

Bender, Harold S. and John Due south. Oyer. (1989). Historiography: Anabaptist. Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. Retrieved 21 Apr 2022, from https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Historiography:_Anabaptist&oldid=166257.

---

Adapted by permission of Herald Printing, Harrisonburg, Virginia, from Mennonite Encyclopedia, Vol. 2, pp. 751-756; v. v, pp. 378-382. All rights reserved.

©1996-2022 by the Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. All rights reserved.

newmanancen1954.blogspot.com

Source: https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Historiography%3A_Anabaptist

Share this post